Skip to main content
An official website of the United States government
Grant Details

Grant Number: 5R21CA202552-02 Interpret this number
Primary Investigator: Murphy, Adam
Organization: Northwestern University At Chicago
Project Title: Comparative Effectiveness of Genomics Assay for Active Surveillance Failure Prediction in African American Men: the Impact of Genetic Ancestry and Socioeconomic Status.
Fiscal Year: 2017


 DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): Prostate Cancer (PCa) is the most common malignancy in men but overtreatment is a major public health concern. To address this, Genomic Health Inc. in collaboration with academic and military hospitals validated a 17-gene relative expression assay to predict the probability of adverse pathologic features at the time of radical prostatectomy to improve the safety of active surveillance. Their Oncotype DX (ODX) assay improves the prognostic accuracy beyond standard clinical parameters at the time of biopsy. The ODX GPS is scaled from 0-100 and increases the number of men deemed eligible for active surveillance by decreasing the pre-test probability of adverse pathology and allows patients and providers to confidently elect active surveillance to avoid upfront treatment morbidity. ODX has been validated in largely European American (EA) populations but has yet to be adequately assessed in high-risk African American (AA) men. Our overarching hypothesis is that the prognostic accuracy of Oncotype DX varies by race and by socioeconomic status and genetic ancestry among AAs. This is significant since AAs have the highest risk of PCa and PCa mortality and are more likely to harbor adverse pathology in their prostate despite being eligible for active surveillance by clinical parameters. Risk of aggressive PCa varies across studies in AA men based on socioeconomic factors including insurance, education and income. Moreover, gene expression varies significantly between AA and EA prostate tumors. Given this, ODX can be dangerous for AAs if prediction performance is poorer or differs significantly between AAs and EAs or between subpopulations of AAs with clinically localized prostate cancer (CLPCa). To assess the prediction performance of ODX in AAs with CLPCa, we propose the following Specific Aims: (1) to compare the effectiveness of the ODX GPS as a predictor of adverse pathology in archived specimen from 100 AA and 50 EA men with CLPCa; (2) to compare the prediction performance of the GPS for adverse pathology in archived specimen from 150 AAs with CLPCa from divergent socio-demographic (income, education, insurance status) backgrounds; (3) to assess for variation in GPS prediction performance in 100 previously recruited AAs with CLPCa by degree of genetic European or African ancestry. Should this comparative effectiveness study reveal variations in prediction performance by race, socioeconomic status or genetic ancestry, a calibrated GPS score could be provided. Alternatively, if the ODX assay inadequately measures risk of adverse pathology we prevent its use in men of African ancestry. In either scenario we improve the safety of active surveillance for a high-risk PCa population.


A 17-Gene Panel Genomic Prostate Score Has Similar Predictive Accuracy for Adverse Pathology at Radical Prostatectomy in African American and European American Men.
Authors: Murphy A.B. , Carbunaru S. , Nettey O.S. , Gornbein C. , Dixon M.A. , Macias V. , Sharifi R. , Kittles R.A. , Yang X. , Kajdacsy-Balla A. , et al. .
Source: Urology, 2020 Aug; 142, p. 166-173.
EPub date: 2020-04-08.
PMID: 32277993
Related Citations

Physiologic serum 1,25 dihydroxyvitamin D is inversely associated with prostatic Ki67 staining in a diverse sample of radical prostatectomy patients.
Authors: Rosenberg A. , Nettey O.S. , Gogana P. , Sheikh U. , Macias V. , Kajdacsy-Balla A. , Sharifi R. , Kittles R.A. , Murphy A.B. .
Source: Cancer causes & control : CCC, 2019 Feb; 30(2), p. 207-214.
EPub date: 2019-02-07.
PMID: 30730018
Related Citations

African-American Prostate Cancer Disparities.
Authors: Smith Z.L. , Eggener S.E. , Murphy A.B. .
Source: Current urology reports, 2017-08-14; 18(10), p. 81.
EPub date: 2017-08-14.
PMID: 28808871
Related Citations

Reply to E. Roca et al.
Authors: Nyame Y.A. , Murphy A.B. , Jordan G. , Gogana P. , Hollowell C.M.P. , Catalona W.J. , Kittles R. .
Source: Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology, 2016-10-20; 34(30), p. 3710-3711.
PMID: 27458284
Related Citations

Back to Top