Skip to main content
An official website of the United States government
Grant Details

Grant Number: 5R01CA120799-05 Interpret this number
Primary Investigator: Herzog, Thaddeus
Organization: University Of Hawaii At Manoa
Project Title: Testing Alternative Stage Models of Smoking Cessation: an Intervention Study
Fiscal Year: 2011


DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): Stage theories of health behavior have been influential over the past 20 years. In the case of smoking cessation, the appeal and potential of a stage model is easily understood. Whereas many variables are associated with smoking cessation, it is difficult to organize these variables into a coherent theory of how people quit smoking. A stage model could help bring structure to these variables in a way that would inform interventions. If smokers could be arranged in an ordered set of stages, then interventions could be designed for each stage to foster progressive stage movements leading ultimately to cessation. The intuitive appeal of a stage model for smoking cessation is reflected by the widespread use of the stages of change over past 20 years. The stage of change construct is the linchpin of a larger model known as the Transtheoretical Model (TTM). However, several researchers recently have concluded that the TTM is insufficiently supported by empirical evidence. The hypothesis of the current application is that the stage of change construct systematically underestimates motivation to quit smoking, and that this systematic underestimation undermines research and interventions based on the TTM. An intervention study is proposed in which participants receive stage-matched interventions for smoking cessation. The three study conditions will use three different staging systems to determine the stage of each smoker. One staging system will be the stages of change. A second staging method will be an alterative developed by the PI. Past research has shown that these two systems produce significantly different stage distributions, and that the alternative algorithm classifies smokers as being significantly more motivated to quit compared to the stages of change algorithm. A third "system" is a control condition in which all smokers are treated as though they were highly motivated to quit. The hypothesis of the proposed study is that participants staged using the alternative staging system will evince greater rates of cessation and greater increases in motivation to quit smoking compared to participants staged with the stage of change algorithm, or participants assigned to the control condition. Given the prominence of the TTM in public health research and practice, this study could have far reaching implications for preventing cancer and other diseases by enhancing the effectiveness of smoking cessation interventions.


Reasons for quitting cigarette smoking and electronic cigarette use for cessation help.
Authors: Pokhrel P. , Herzog T.A. .
Source: Psychology of addictive behaviors : journal of the Society of Psychologists in Addictive Behaviors, 2015 Mar; 29(1), p. 114-21.
EPub date: 2014-09-01.
PMID: 25180551
Related Citations

Short-term fluctuations in motivation to quit smoking in a sample of smokers in Hawaii.
Authors: Herzog T. , Pokhrel P. , Kawamoto C.T. .
Source: Substance use & misuse, 2015 Jan; 50(2), p. 236-41.
EPub date: 2014-10-22.
PMID: 25338289
Related Citations

Correlates of use of electronic cigarettes versus nicotine replacement therapy for help with smoking cessation.
Authors: Pokhrel P. , Little M.A. , Fagan P. , Kawamoto C.T. , Herzog T.A. .
Source: Addictive behaviors, 2014 Dec; 39(12), p. 1869-73.
EPub date: 2014-08-07.
PMID: 25129173
Related Citations

Intention to quit betel quid: a comparison of betel quid chewers and cigarette smokers.
Authors: Little M.A. , Pokhrel P. , Murphy K.L. , Kawamoto C.T. , Suguitan G.S. , Herzog T.A. .
Source: Oral health and dental management, 2014 Jun; 13(2), p. 512-8.
PMID: 24984674
Related Citations

Smokers who try e-cigarettes to quit smoking: findings from a multiethnic study in Hawaii.
Authors: Pokhrel P. , Fagan P. , Little M.A. , Kawamoto C.T. , Herzog T.A. .
Source: American journal of public health, 2013 Sep; 103(9), p. e57-62.
EPub date: 2013-07-18.
PMID: 23865700
Related Citations

Ethnic differences in smoking rate, nicotine dependence, and cessation-related variables among adult smokers in Hawaii.
Authors: Herzog T.A. , Pokhrel P. .
Source: Journal of community health, 2012 Dec; 37(6), p. 1226-33.
PMID: 22438074
Related Citations

Back to Top