Skip to main content
Grant Details

Grant Number: 5R21CA127818-02 Interpret this number
Primary Investigator: Toll, Benjamin
Organization: Yale University
Project Title: Promoting Tobacco and Cancer Control: Message Framing for Telephone Quitline Call
Fiscal Year: 2008


DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): A substantial body of evidence shows that telephone counseling for smoking cessation is more effective than less intense interventions. Moreover, Prospect Theory suggests that because smoking cessation is a prevention behavior with a fairly certain outcome (i.e., quitting is clearly linked to preventing health problems), messages framed in terms of potential gains (i.e., benefits), in contrast to potential losses, should be more persuasive in motivating smoking cessation. Indeed, pilot data from four previous studies shows that gain-framed messages are more effective in encouraging smoking cessation. Thus, building on a decade of research focused on optimizing messages for cancer prevention, we intend to compare New York State Smokers' Quitline counseling and print messages that are either exclusively gain-framed (e.g., you will live longer if you quit smoking) to standard care, which has elements of both gain-framed and loss-framed (e.g., you will die sooner if you continue to smoke) messages. Because this study will compare 2 different types of counseling, no callers to the quitline will be refused services, removing an important barrier to research on quitlines. This study will have two phases. In Phase I, a Pre-Pilot Study will be conducted to: 1) develop the gain-framed counseling protocol and print materials, and 2) train Quitline Specialists such that those in the exclusively gain-framed condition provide primarily gain-framed messages. In Phase II, a randomized pilot clinical trial will be conducted with 2,500 Quitline callers to compare exclusively gain-framed counseling + gain-framed print materials (GF condition) to standard care Quitline counseling + standard print materials (SC condition). Efficacy data from this trial will be used to determine effect size estimates for both 1-week and 3-month self- reported point prevalence abstinence rates. Approximately 60% of callers will receive short-term nicotine replacement therapy. Mediators of message framing effects will also be examined. It is our hope that findings from this study will allow us to develop effective counseling and print materials that can be used for a large- scale, R01 research grant to fund a study testing the effectiveness of gain-framed counseling and print materials for smoking cessation amongst callers to multiple state quitlines. If message framing is shown to enhance treatment outcome in a large-scale study, message framing interventions with quitline counselors could be translated for use by the entire NY state quitline and other quitlines across the country. This would provide a cost-effective method for increasing the effectiveness of a moderate intensity intervention for smoking cessation that has the potential to reach millions of smokers, thereby bolstering tobacco and cancer control efforts across the United States. Studying ways to improve telephone quitline counseling for smokers may improve tobacco control interventions by enhancing quit rates of callers to quitlines. As telephone quitlines have the potential to reach millions of smokers annually, better interventions can greatly impact tobacco and cancer control efforts in the United States.


Tobacco quitlines need to assess and intervene with callers' hazardous drinking.
Authors: Toll B.A. , Cummings K.M. , O'Malley S.S. , Carlin-Menter S. , McKee S.A. , Hyland A. , Wu R. , Hopkins J. , Celestino P. .
Source: Alcoholism, clinical and experimental research, 2012 Sep; 36(9), p. 1653-8.
EPub date: 2012-06-15.
PMID: 22703028
Related Citations

How do perceptions about cessation outcomes moderate the effectiveness of a gain-framed smoking cessation telephone counseling intervention?
Authors: Latimer-Cheung A.E. , Fucito L.M. , Carlin-Menter S. , Rodriguez J. , Raymond L. , Salovey P. , Makuch R. , Cummings K.M. , Toll B.A. .
Source: Journal of health communication, 2012; 17(9), p. 1081-98.
EPub date: 2012-07-05.
PMID: 22765277
Related Citations

Nicotine dependence as a moderator of a quitline-based message framing intervention.
Authors: Fucito L.M. , Latimer A.E. , Carlin-Menter S. , Salovey P. , Cummings K.M. , Makuch R.W. , Toll B.A. .
Source: Drug and alcohol dependence, 2011-04-01; 114(2-3), p. 229-32.
EPub date: 2010-10-30.
PMID: 21036492
Related Citations

The identification of framed messages in the New York State Smokers' Quitline materials.
Authors: Latimer A.E. , Green K.E. , Schmid K. , Tomasone J. , Abrams S. , Cummings K.M. , Celestino P. , Salovey P. , Seshadri S. , Toll B.A. .
Source: Health education research, 2010 Feb; 25(1), p. 54-60.
EPub date: 2009-08-05.
PMID: 19656799
Related Citations

Randomized trial: Quitline specialist training in gain-framed vs standard-care messages for smoking cessation.
Authors: Toll B.A. , Martino S. , Latimer A. , Salovey P. , O'Malley S. , Carlin-Menter S. , Hopkins J. , Wu R. , Celestino P. , Cummings K.M. .
Source: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 2010-01-20; 102(2), p. 96-106.
EPub date: 2010-01-07.
PMID: 20056957
Related Citations

Back to Top