Skip to main content
Grant Details

Grant Number: 5R01CA104721-03 Interpret this number
Primary Investigator: Schwartz, Lisa
Organization: Dartmouth College
Project Title: Improving the Quality of News Reporting on Medicine
Fiscal Year: 2006


Abstract

DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): Context -- The news media has a powerful influence on public perceptions about health. Several studies, however, have raised questions about how well the press covers medical issues, pointing out errors and misleading statistical presentations. Such problems are not surprising. Journalists generally receive no training in how to interpret or discuss medical research. And medical journals, the most common source of stories, currently do little to make the journalist's job easier. Long-term objectives -- To help journalists to better cover medical research and to help improve communication between journalists and the medical journals, we will: (1) Develop and evaluate news report quality criteria for media reporting on medical issues; (2) Develop and evaluate press guides to facilitate and standardize communication between medical journals and journalists; (3) Develop and evaluate a primer to train journalists in how to interpret and report on medical research. Specific Aims Aim I: Conduct formal psychometric testing to establish the validity, reliability and sensibility of the news report quality criteria as an outcome measure for subsequent studies in Aims II and III. Aim II: Work with 4 major medical journals (Ann Intern Med, BMJ, JAMA, and J NaU Cancer Inst) to refine the press guide and develop a process for its implementation. We will evaluate how journalists respond to the press guide and conduct randomized trials to see whether press guides improve the quality of reporting (using Aim criteria). Aim III: Develop a primer for journalists with practical advice on how to interpret and report on medical research. We will assess the effect of the primer in a randomized controlled trial involving staff newspaper healthcare journalists. The main outcome measures will be whether the primer improves critical reading skills and the quality of reporting (using Aim I criteria). Significance -- this project will help by developing methods to evaluate media coverage of medical issues and by promoting balanced health messages in the media. Balanced news coverage will help patients (and their physicians) better understand the importance of research findings and the benefits of medical interventions -- in turn, this will help to promote informed decision making.



Publications

Do physicians understand cancer screening statistics? A national survey of primary care physicians in the United States.
Authors: Wegwarth O. , Schwartz L.M. , Woloshin S. , Gaissmaier W. , Gigerenzer G. .
Source: Annals of internal medicine, 2012-03-06; 156(5), p. 340-9.
PMID: 22393129
Related Citations

Promoting healthy skepticism in the news: helping journalists get it right.
Authors: Woloshin S. , Schwartz L.M. , Kramer B.S. .
Source: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 2009-12-02; 101(23), p. 1596-9.
EPub date: 2009-11-20.
PMID: 19933445
Related Citations

Press releases by academic medical centers: not so academic?
Authors: Woloshin S. , Schwartz L.M. , Casella S.L. , Kennedy A.T. , Larson R.J. .
Source: Annals of internal medicine, 2009-05-05; 150(9), p. 613-8.
PMID: 19414840
Related Citations

Using a drug facts box to communicate drug benefits and harms: two randomized trials.
Authors: Schwartz L.M. , Woloshin S. , Welch H.G. .
Source: Annals of internal medicine, 2009-04-21; 150(8), p. 516-27.
EPub date: 2009-02-16.
PMID: 19221371
Related Citations

The risk of death by age, sex, and smoking status in the United States: putting health risks in context.
Authors: Woloshin S. , Schwartz L.M. , Welch H.G. .
Source: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 2008-06-18; 100(12), p. 845-53.
EPub date: 2008-06-10.
PMID: 18544745
Related Citations

The drug facts box: providing consumers with simple tabular data on drug benefit and harm.
Authors: Schwartz L.M. , Woloshin S. , Welch H.G. .
Source: Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making, 2007 Sep-Oct; 27(5), p. 655-62.
EPub date: 2007-09-14.
PMID: 17873258
Related Citations

The effectiveness of a primer to help people understand risk: two randomized trials in distinct populations.
Authors: Woloshin S. , Schwartz L.M. , Welch H.G. .
Source: Annals of internal medicine, 2007-02-20; 146(4), p. 256-65.
PMID: 17310049
Related Citations

Ratio measures in leading medical journals: structured review of accessibility of underlying absolute risks.
Authors: Schwartz L.M. , Woloshin S. , Dvorin E.L. , Welch H.G. .
Source: BMJ (Clinical research ed.), 2006-12-16; 333(7581), p. 1248.
EPub date: 2006-10-23.
PMID: 17060338
Related Citations

Giving legs to restless legs: a case study of how the media helps make people sick.
Authors: Woloshin S. , Schwartz L.M. .
Source: PLoS medicine, 2006 Apr; 3(4), p. e170.
EPub date: 2006-04-11.
PMID: 16597175
Related Citations

Patients and medical statistics. Interest, confidence, and ability.
Authors: Woloshin S. , Schwartz L.M. , Welch H.G. .
Source: Journal of general internal medicine, 2005 Nov; 20(11), p. 996-1000.
PMID: 16307623
Related Citations

Reducing the risk that patients get it wrong.
Authors: Woloshin S. , Schwartz L.M. .
Source: Gastroenterology, 2005 Aug; 129(2), p. 748-50.
PMID: 16083729
Related Citations

The exaggerated relations between diet, body weight and mortality: the case for a categorical data approach.
Authors: Welch H.G. , Schwartz L.M. , Woloshin S. .
Source: CMAJ : Canadian Medical Association journal = journal de l'Association medicale canadienne, 2005-03-29; 172(7), p. 891-5.
PMID: 15795411
Related Citations




Back to Top