Skip to main content
An official website of the United States government
Grant Details

Grant Number: 5R01CA089122-03 Interpret this number
Primary Investigator: Lipkus, Isaac
Organization: Duke University
Project Title: Message Framing Effects on Youth's Smoking Behavior
Fiscal Year: 2004


DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): Adolescent and young adult smoking cessation programs have applied stage-based and social psychological models of attitude-behavior relations. As teens and young adults experiment with and continue to smoke, they perceive the positive smoking outcomes as more salient than the negative outcomes. As they become regular smokers, their positive attitudes and outcome expectancies towards smoking become more solidified. Conversely, as they contemplate quitting, negative attitudes and negative outcome expectancies become more salient. These findings suggest that there may be optimal moments when the communication of positive and negative aspects of smoking may be most influential at affecting the smoking trajectory. Unfortunately, the extant literature provides very little insights about how to best communicate persuasively the pros of not smoking and cons of smoking among older teens and young adults at various stages of smoking, and possible mechanisms for their presumed effectiveness. Evidence across several health behaviors, and from our pilot data, suggest that people are persuaded differently by messages framed as gains or losses. Gain-framed messages highlight the advantages of either engaging or not engaging in a course of action; loss-frame messages highlight the disadvantages of either engaging or not engaging in a course of action. Larger trials testing the persuasiveness of gain- or loss-framed messages to affect older teens and young adult smokers' (e.g., community college students) intentions to quit and quit attempts, and the mechanisms for their presumed effectiveness are lacking. These issues form the bases of this three-year study. Employing a two-group (gain vs. loss-frame video) pre-post (one and six month) longitudinal experimental design using approximately 390 community college students between the ages of 18-24, the study examines how gain- and loss-framed messages interact with smoking stages of change, as defined by the Transtheoretical Model, to affect: 1) the motivation and intention to quit, and serious quit attempts, and 2) mechanisms for the presumed effectiveness of gain- versus loss-framed messages to affect the aforementioned outcomes as a function of stage. This study is the first to attempt to assess reactions toward persuasively framed cessation messages on the motivation/intentions to quit and quit attempts and mediators for their presumed effectiveness as a function of stage in rarely studied populations of community college student smokers.


College smokers' estimates of their probabilities of remaining a smoker in the near future.
Authors: Lipkus I. , Shepperd J. .
Source: Journal of health psychology, 2009 May; 14(4), p. 547-55.
PMID: 19383655
Related Citations

The effects of providing lung age and respiratory symptoms feedback on community college smokers' perceived smoking-related health risks, worries and desire to quit.
Authors: Lipkus I.M. , Prokhorov A.V. .
Source: Addictive behaviors, 2007 Mar; 32(3), p. 516-32.
EPub date: 2006-07-07.
PMID: 16824688
Related Citations

Interest in testing for genetic susceptibility to lung cancer among Black college students "at risk" of becoming cigarette smokers.
Authors: McBride C.M. , Lipkus I.M. , Jolly D. , Lyna P. .
Source: Cancer epidemiology, biomarkers & prevention : a publication of the American Association for Cancer Research, cosponsored by the American Society of Preventive Oncology, 2005 Dec; 14(12), p. 2978-81.
PMID: 16365020
Related Citations

Back to Top