Skip to main content
Grant Details

Grant Number: 5R29CA069223-06 Interpret this number
Primary Investigator: Tenhave, Thomas
Organization: University Of Pennsylvania
Project Title: Mixed Model Effects for Discrete Biomedical Data
Fiscal Year: 1999
Back to top


Statistical methodology is to be extended to accommodate unique statistical problems that arise in several different biomedical studies involving the estimation of within-cluster effects. Examples of such effects include differences in response to chemical toxicity among groups of litters within blocks, within-subject differences in treatment response among tumors in different organs across time, within-subject differences in risk of periodontal diseases among different regions of the dentition across time, and within-subject treatment effects in a cross-over study of bioequivalence. These examples arise in four areas of application: 1) a developmental toxicity study of the synergistic effect of combinations of possible carcinogens ; 2) a comparison of treatment responses of metastatic tumors in different organs that originated from renal cell carcinoma; 3) an observational study of temporal changes in the spatial distribution of periodontal disease ina the dentition; and 4) an investigation of the bioequivalence of different formulations of a drug with respect to a discrete response. These areas of research present a number of unresolved issues regarding mixed effects discrete response models that are the focus of this proposal. First, mixed effects models that accommodate multiple endpoints are addressed. Three cases are to be examined: 1) multiple discrete endpoints; 2) discrete and continuous endpoints; and 3) multiple discrete endpoints with a discrete time failure response. For case 1), a hybrid of random effects and marginal models is proposed. For case 2), an extension of measurement error mixed effects models is considered. And for case 3), a mixed effect ordinal response model conditional on a discrete time failure response is discussed. Additional issues include adapting mixed effects discrete response models to accommodate random cluster sizes (e.g., litter sizes and numbers of tumors for a given subject) and negative intracluster correlations (e.g., strong litter mates benefiting at the expense of weak litter mates). Finally, the analysis of bioequivalence discrete response data has demonstrated differences in confidence-interval- based inference between population-averaged and mixed effects logistic regression models. It is proposed that other link functions be investigated that lead to consistent confidence interval-based inference for bioequivalence in this context.

Back to top


Deviations from the population-averaged versus cluster-specific relationship for clustered binary data.
Authors: Ten Have T.R. , Ratcliffe S.J. , Reboussin B.A. , Miller M.E. .
Source: Statistical methods in medical research, 2004 Feb; 13(1), p. 3-16.
PMID: 14746438
Related Citations

The compliance score as a regressor in randomized trials.
Authors: Joffe M.M. , Ten Have T.R. , Brensinger C. .
Source: Biostatistics (Oxford, England), 2003 Jul; 4(3), p. 327-40.
PMID: 12925501
Related Citations

Mixed effects logistic regression models for multiple longitudinal binary functional limitation responses with informative drop-out and confounding by baseline outcomes.
Authors: Ten H. , Reboussin B.A. , Miller M.E. , Kunselman A. .
Source: Biometrics, 2002 Mar; 58(1), p. 137-44.
PMID: 11890309
Related Citations

Mixed effects logistic regression models for longitudinal ordinal functional response data with multiple-cause drop-out from the longitudinal study of aging.
Authors: Ten Have T.R. , Miller M.E. , Reboussin B.A. , James M.K. .
Source: Biometrics, 2000 Mar; 56(1), p. 279-87.
PMID: 10783807
Related Citations

A comparison of mixed effects logistic regression models for binary response data with two nested levels of clustering.
Authors: Ten Have T.R. , Kunselman A.R. , Tran L. .
Source: Statistics in medicine, 1999-04-30; 18(8), p. 947-60.
PMID: 10363333
Related Citations

Mixed effects models with bivariate and univariate association parameters for longitudinal bivariate binary response data.
Authors: Ten Have T.R. , Morabia A. .
Source: Biometrics, 1999 Mar; 55(1), p. 85-93.
PMID: 11318182
Related Citations

Accommodating negative intracluster correlation with a mixed effects logistic model for bivariate binary data.
Authors: Ten Have T.R. , Kunselman A. , Zharichenko E. .
Source: Journal of biopharmaceutical statistics, 1998 Mar; 8(1), p. 131-49.
PMID: 9547432
Related Citations

Mixed effects logistic regression models for longitudinal binary response data with informative drop-out.
Authors: Ten Have T.R. , Kunselman A.R. , Pulkstenis E.P. , Landis J.R. .
Source: Biometrics, 1998 Mar; 54(1), p. 367-83.
PMID: 9544529
Related Citations

Interaction fallacy.
Authors: Morabia A. , Ten Have T. , Landis J.R. .
Source: Journal of clinical epidemiology, 1997 Jul; 50(7), p. 809-12.
PMID: 9253392
Related Citations

Population-averaged and cluster-specific models for clustered ordinal response data.
Authors: Ten Have T.R. , Landis J.R. , Hartzel J. .
Source: Statistics in medicine, 1996-12-15; 15(23), p. 2573-88.
PMID: 8961464
Related Citations

A mixed effects model for multivariate ordinal response data including correlated discrete failure times with ordinal responses.
Authors: Ten Have T.R. .
Source: Biometrics, 1996 Jun; 52(2), p. 473-91.
PMID: 8672699
Related Citations

Comparison of two approaches to analyzing correlated binary data in developmental toxicity studies.
Authors: Ten Have T.R. , Hartzel T. .
Source: Teratology, 1995 Nov; 52(5), p. 267-76.
PMID: 8838250
Related Citations

Back to Top