Skip to main content
An official website of the United States government
Grant Details

Grant Number: 5R01CA255382-03 Interpret this number
Primary Investigator: Tehranifar, Parisa
Organization: Columbia University Health Sciences
Project Title: DE-Implementation of Mammography Overuse in Older Racially and Ethnically Diverse Women
Fiscal Year: 2023


PROJECT SUMMARY De-implementation is recognized as a critical but understudied area within implementation science (IS). Research is needed to determine the optimal methods and approaches for identifying, selecting, and tailoring de-implementation strategies. De-implementation of routine cancer screening in older adults, such as mammography screening for breast cancer, offers excellent opportunities for both advancing the science of de- implementation and improving care delivery and health outcomes in older adults. While national guidelines do not support routine mammography in older women and recommend consideration of morbidities, life expectancy and patients’ informed preferences, ~56% of women ≥75 years report receiving mammography, including 50% of women with life expectancy <10 years. Our preliminary research identified multi-level barriers and facilitators to de-implementation of mammography overuse among older women at the organizational (e.g. system alerts, patient reminder letters), provider/clinic (e.g., knowledge, clinic norms), and patient (e.g. habit, knowledge) levels. Informed by the Knowledge-to-Action Model, we propose a study for de-implementation of mammography overuse in older women (i.e., reducing the frequency or cessation of mammography) in older women across a large healthcare system serving a racially/ethnically diverse population in New York City. In Aim 1, we will identify a range of de-implementation strategies at the patient, provider, and organizational levels for reducing mammography overuse in women ages ≥75 years. We will use a crowdsourcing method, successfully applied in an emerging participatory IS approach (innovation tournament) to generate rapid data collection from diverse stakeholders (80-100 patients/family members, 80-100 providers/administrators from the community and multiple healthcare systems) on factors that influence de-implementation. Combining this data with our rich qualitative preliminary data, and principles from Dual Process Theory, we will develop distinct de-implementation strategies for refinement in Aim 2. In Aim 2, we will prioritize and tailor de-implementation strategies at patient, provider/clinic, and organizational levels. We will recruit 12-15 experts to prioritize strategies based on feasibility and acceptability, and propose key attributes (e.g., duration, frequency, content) for each strategy, and employ discrete choice experiment to elicit patient (n=75-100) and provider (n=75-100) preferences for modifiable attributes of each prioritized strategy. In Aim 3, we will evaluate the feasibility, acceptability, and use of the tailored de-implementation strategies in a pilot cluster randomized trial (8 clinics). Using a sequential mixed-methods design, we will assess use of strategies, de-adoption outcomes (e.g. reduction of mammography overuse), and theoretical mechanisms of strategies at the patient, provider, and organizational levels. Data will establish feasibility and provide preliminary data for effectiveness of strategies to be tested in future Hybrid 2 trial, and lay the groundwork for advancing de-implementation frameworks and methodological approaches for selecting de-implementation strategies to reduce the use of low-value care.


Enhancing Impact: A Call to Action for Equitable Implementation Science.
Authors: Shelton R.C. , Brownson R.C. .
Source: Prevention science : the official journal of the Society for Prevention Research, 2024 Apr; 25(Suppl 1), p. 174-189.
EPub date: 2023-10-25.
PMID: 37878237
Related Citations

"It's something I'll do until I die": A qualitative examination into why older women in the U.S. continue screening mammography.
Authors: Brotzman L.E. , Shelton R.C. , Austin J.D. , Rodriguez C.B. , Agovino M. , Moise N. , Tehranifar P. .
Source: Cancer medicine, 2022 Oct; 11(20), p. 3854-3862.
EPub date: 2022-05-26.
PMID: 35616300
Related Citations

Revisiting concepts of evidence in implementation science.
Authors: Brownson R.C. , Shelton R.C. , Geng E.H. , Glasgow R.E. .
Source: Implementation science : IS, 2022-04-12; 17(1), p. 26.
EPub date: 2022-04-12.
PMID: 35413917
Related Citations

A mixed-methods study of multi-level factors influencing mammography overuse among an older ethnically diverse screening population: implications for de-implementation.
Authors: Austin J.D. , Tehranifar P. , Rodriguez C.B. , Brotzman L. , Agovino M. , Ziazadeh D. , Moise N. , Shelton R.C. .
Source: Implementation science communications, 2021-09-26; 2(1), p. 110.
EPub date: 2021-09-26.
PMID: 34565481
Related Citations

Back to Top